Dealing with a volatile stock market can be difficult. To help
you get through this period, we've included several articles on
the topic:
If you have any questions or would like help reviewing your
current portfolio, please contact us at (612) 496-1019 or Fred@fjfinancial.com.
Coping with Volatility
Keep repeating to yourself, "I'm investing for the long
term. Short-term fluctuations are an expected part of investing."
Still having a difficult time remaining calm during this volatile
period? Try these strategies:
- Review the reasons why you have
invested. If you haven't done so yet, put your target
asset allocation in writing. Indicate why you have adopted this
strategy and what long-term returns and short-term losses you
expect from this allocation. You may also want to write down
the same information for each individual investment. Then, when
market volatility makes you nervous, review your written reasons
for investing as you did. That reminder should help keep you
focused on the long term.
- Check if you should rebalance your
portfolio. Revisit your asset allocation strategy,
comparing your current allocation to your desired allocation.
Due to the strong stock market of the past several years, your
portfolio may be overweighted with stocks. The recent volatility
in the markets may now make it apparent that there is too much
risk in your portfolio. You may want to reallocate some of those
stock investments to other alternatives.
- Don't review the value of your investments
too frequently. You should only be invested in stocks
for long-term goals, so it's not important to review your stock
values on a day-to-day basis. Instead, limit yourself to a monthly
review.
- Determine how much of a loss you
can withstand. Calculate the total value of your stock
portfolio and reduce it by 20%, the official definition of a
bear market. If that loss is more than you can comfortably withstand,
consider shifting some stocks to other assets. Be realistic about
how much loss you can withstand. It's better to sell now than
to find out at a market bottom that you feel compelled to sell.
- Keep in mind the tax aspects of
selling. While it is tempting to lock in some of your
profits, you may have to pay taxes on those gains if the stocks
aren't held in tax-advantaged accounts. The capital gains tax
rate on assets held over one year is 20% (10% for taxpayers in
the 15% tax bracket). It may take you longer to overcome the
tax bite than to overcome a bear market.
- Reacquaint yourself with the stock
market's past history. While the stock market suffers
declines in some periods, over the long term the trend has been
upward. Of course, past performance is not a guarantee of future
results. Even though short-term setbacks can make even the most
knowledgeable investors anxious, take comfort in the fact that
staying in the market over the long term, through different market
cycles, can help manage the effects of market fluctuations. See
the article "How Time Helps Manage Risk"
for more details.
- Continue investing based on your
investment strategy. During periods of volatility,
it's tempting to abandon your plan due to fears about where the
market is heading. Instead, stick with your original investment
plan, reminding yourself that you are purchasing stocks at low
prices.
Still need additional reassurance? Please call if you'd like
to review the reasons why you invested as you did or if you'd
like to review your investment portfolio in light of the current
situation.
Back to topics.
Risk and Your Stocks
How much the major market indexes have declined during this
volatile period has been widely reported. But how have your stocks
performed? Have they experienced sharper or milder declines than
the indexes?
Answering these questions will help you determine how much
risk your stocks are subject to. Basically, stocks are affected
by two types of risk - market risk and nonmarket risk. Nonmarket
risk, also called specific risk, is the risk that events specific
to a company or its industry will adversely affect the stock's
price. For instance, an increase in the cost of oil would be expected
to adversely affect the prices of stocks for the entire oil industry,
while a major management change would only affect that company.
Market risk, on the other hand, is the risk that a particular
stock's price will be affected by overall stock market movements.
You can reduce nonmarket risk through diversification. By owning
several different stocks in different industries whose stock prices
have shown little correlation to each other, you reduce the risk
that nonmarket factors will adversely affect your total portfolio.
However, no matter how many stocks you own, you can't totally
eliminate market risk. Beta and standard deviation are two tools
commonly used to measure risk.
Beta
Beta, which can be found in a number of published services,
is a statistical measure of the impact stock market movements
have historically had on a stock's price. By comparing the returns
of the Standard & Poor's 500 (S&P 500) to the returns
of a particular stock, a pattern develops that indicates the security's
exposure to stock market risk.
The S&P 500 is an unmanaged index generally considered
representative of the U.S. stock market and has a beta of 1. A
stock with a beta of 1 means that, on average, it moves parallel
with the S&P 500 - the stock should rise 10% when the S&P
500 rises 10%, while the stock should decline 10% when the S&P
500 declines 10%. A beta greater than 1 indicates that the stock
should rise or fall to a greater extent than movements in the
stock market, while a beta less than 1 means that the stock should
rise or fall to a lesser extent than the S&P 500. Since beta
measures movements on average, you cannot expect an exact correlation
with each market movement.
Standard Deviation
Standard deviation, which can also be found in a number of
published services, measures a stock's volatility, regardless
of the cause. It basically tells you how much the short-term returns
of a stock have moved around its long-term average return. The
most common way to calculate standard deviation is to figure the
deviation from an average monthly return over a three-, five-,
or 10-year period, and then annualize that number. Generally,
the higher the standard deviation, the more volatile the stock
is.
Let's look at an example. Assume you own a stock with an average
return of 10.2% and a standard deviation of 15%. 68% of the time,
you can expect your return to fall within a range of -4.8% to
25.2%, while 95% of the time, you can expect your return to fall
within a range of -19.8% to 40.2%. (This example is provided for
illustrative purposes only and is not intended to project the
performance of a specific investment.)
Taken together, beta and standard deviation can provide important
information about the volatility of your stock investments. If
your stock portfolio is riskier than you realized, you might want
to take steps to reduce that risk by reallocating. Or, when you
invest new funds in the stock market, check the beta and standard
deviation of the stock first. Consider investing in stocks with
betas lower than 1 or with a low standard deviation to help you
reduce the impact of any stock market moves.
Back to topics.
Reassessing Your Risk Tolerance
When you designed your investment strategy, you probably answered
several questions to assess your risk tolerance. But there's nothing
like a real world test to find out how much risk you can tolerate.
While you can't be expected to be comfortable with all of the
recent movements in the stock market, it is instructive to review
how you have handled this volatility. Ask yourself these questions:
- Have I reacted calmly to the recent volatility or have I
been anxious about my stocks' value?
- Do I frequently calculate the value of my stocks, worrying
about any declines in value, or do I only occasionally check
their value?
- How would I react if the stock market continued to decline,
possibly hitting declines that typically qualify as a bear market
(defined as a 20% drop from a market high)?
- How long could I withstand a declining market before I felt
compelled to sell?
These questions are designed to gauge your emotional tolerance
for risk. You can objectively determine your risk tolerance based
on factors like your investment period, income level, asset levels,
debt levels, liquidity, and family responsibilities. But your
emotional tolerance for risk assesses how calmly you can face
market declines.
If the recent market volatility has been difficult to handle,
look for ways to reduce the risk in your portfolio or to become
more comfortable with risk. Some strategies to consider include:
- Diversify your portfolio among several investment categories,
including cash, bonds, and stocks. A properly diversified portfolio
contains a mix of asset types whose values have historically
moved in different directions or in the same direction with different
magnitudes. See the article "Why Bother with
Asset Allocation?" for more details.
- Stay in the stock market through different market cycles.
Remaining in the market over the long term helps to reduce the
risk of receiving a lower return than you expected. See the article
"How Time Helps Manage Risk" for more
details.
- Become familiar with different investments and the risks
they are subject to. Over time, your comfort level with risk
should increase as your understanding increases.
- Maintain reasonable return expectations. Otherwise, you may
become disappointed if an asset does not perform as expected.
- If you want to invest in more aggressive investments but
aren't sure you can handle the risk, start out by investing a
small amount. Increase your exposure as your comfort level increases.
Back to topics.
Why Bother With Asset Allocation?
With the stock market turning in above-average returns the
past few years, many investors have wondered why they should invest
in anything but stocks. But when the stock market turns volatile,
the reasons for adopting an asset allocation strategy start to
look a little clearer:
- It provides a disciplined approach
to diversification. An asset allocation strategy reflects
your personal decisions about how much to invest in different
investment categories, another name for diversification. Since
different investments are affected differently by economic events
and market factors, owning different types of investments helps
reduce the chances that your portfolio will be adversely affected
by a particular type of risk.
- It encourages long-term investing.
An asset allocation strategy is designed to control
the long-term makeup of your portfolio. It should not change
based on economic conditions or fluctuations in the markets.
- It eliminates the need to time investment
decisions. With an asset allocation policy, you may
not have to worry about timing the market, you just have to ensure
that your investments stay within the predetermined percentages
of your total portfolio.
- It helps reduce risk in your portfolio.
Investments with higher returns typically have higher
risk and more volatility in year-to-year returns. Asset allocation
can allow you to combine more aggressive investments with less
aggressive ones. This combination can help you reduce your portfolio's
overall risk.
- It provides a means to adjust your
portfolio's risk over time. The risk in your portfolio
can be adjusted by changing allocations for the different investments
you hold. By anticipating changes in your personal situation,
you can make those changes gradually.
Your asset allocation strategy will depend on a variety of
factors unique to your situation, including your risk tolerance,
return expectations, investment period, and investment preferences.
Back to topics.
How
Time Helps Manage Risk
Although investment returns can fluctuate significantly over
the short term, long-term investing tends to lessen the volatility
of those returns. For example, the chart below shows the range
of total returns for the Standard & Poor's 500 (S&P 500)
for the period from 1949 to 1998. Holding the S&P 500 for
a one-year period during this time produced returns ranging from
52.6% to -26.5%. The range of return narrowed the longer you held
the S&P 500. If held for any 20-year period during that time,
the range of returns was a positive 6.5% to 17.8%.

The S&P 500 is an unmanaged index generally considered
representative of the U.S. stock market. Investors cannot invest
directly in an index. Past performance is not a guarantee of future
performance. Returns are presented for illustrative purposes only
and are not intended to project the performance of a specific
investment. Source: Stocks, Bonds, Bills, and Inflation 1999 Yearbook,
Ibbotson Associates.
Back to topics.
Increasing
the Value of Your Portfolio
The ultimate value of your investment portfolio is determined
by four factors:
- how much you save,
- how long you invest,
- the rate of return earned on your investments, and
- how much is paid in investment costs and taxes.
Of these four factors, it's tempting to concentrate on rate
of return, especially during the past several years when above-average
stock market returns have boosted the value of many portfolios.
However, when the market becomes volatile, how long those above-average
returns can be sustained comes into question. Thus, to continue
the growth in your portfolio, it may be time to concentrate on
the other three factors. Some strategies to consider include:
- Save more. Even modest
changes in the amount you invest can dramatically affect your
portfolio's value. Consider the example of a 35-year-old who
is debating making annual investments of 6% ($3,000) or 8% ($4,000)
of his $50,000 salary. If he earns 8% compounded annually, his
nest egg at age 65 would equal $339,850 with 6% contributions
and $453,133 with 8% contributions. Each increase of 2% of his
salary would mean additional investments of $30,000 over 30 years,
but would increase the ending balance by $113,283.*
- Invest sooner. The compounding
of earnings can have a dramatic impact on the ultimate size of
your portfolio. Consider the following example. Four individuals,
ages 20, 30, 40, and 50, each invest $5,000 this year. What will
that balance equal when each individual reaches age 65, assuming
an 8% return compounded annually? The 50-year-old will have $15,861,
the 40-year-old will have $34,242, the 30-year-old will have
$73,927, and the 20-year-old will have $159,602. Even though
all invested the same amount, the 20-year-old will have a much
larger balance due to the compounding of earnings.*
- Invest in a tax-efficient manner.
Using strategies that defer the payment of taxes for
as long as possible can make a substantial difference in your
portfolio's ultimate size. For example, a recent study found
that high-net-worth individuals could increase their annual total
return by at least 2% by using tax-efficient investment strategies
(Source: Trusts and Estates, March 1998). There are a number
of strategies to help you invest in a tax-efficient manner. Consider
utilizing tax-deferred investment vehicles, such as 401(k) plans
and individual retirement accounts, which defer the payment of
taxes until sometime in the future. Or emphasize investments
that generate capital gains rather than ordinary income. Minimize
turnover in your portfolio, so you can let unrealized capital
gains grow for many years.
* These examples are provided for illustrative purposes only
and are not intended to project the performance of any specific
investment. They do not take into consideration the payment of
commissions or any taxes that may be due.
Back to topics.
The Economy and Your Investments
Recent events have shown how intricate the relationship between
the economy and investment performance can be. One day the market
is reeling from concerns that inflation is increasing. Those concerns
are calmed only to find the market worried about corporate profits.
Stocks and bonds can be significantly impacted by three statistics
- interest rates, inflation, and corporate profits. The trend
in these three statistics will depend in large part on the economy's
stage in the business cycle:
- As a recession begins, interest rates are poised to decrease,
corporate profits are falling, and inflation is either stable
or rising. Typically, stocks may fall because of disappointing
earnings and bonds can rally in anticipation of falling interest
rates.
- Toward the end of a recession, interest rates, corporate
profits, and inflation are all falling. Stocks can typically
start to rise as investors anticipate an economic recovery.
- At the beginning of an expansion, interest rates are still
falling, corporate profits start to rise, and inflation continues
to decline. This is generally a good time for stocks, as evidenced
by the situation in the United States for the past several years.
- As the expansion ages, interest rates start to rise, corporate
profits continue to increase, but there is now concern about
inflation. Stocks may continue to do well until fears of a downturn
set in.
The reason so much attention is being paid to inflation now
is because there is concern that we may be heading toward recession.
Compounding that concern is the fact that the Federal Reserve
has expressed its willingness to increase interest rates at the
first sign of increasing inflation. The markets are likely to
remain volatile until these concerns are resolved in investors'
minds.
Back to topics.
Copyright © 2000. This newsletter intends
to offer factual and up-to-date information on the subjects discussed,
but should not be regarded as a complete analysis of these subjects.
The appropriate professional advisers should be consulted before
implementing any options presented. No party assumes liability
for any loss or damage resulting from errors or omissions or reliance
on or use of this material.
FX1999-1025-0057